2018
- Brandon Johns – University of Michigan
2017
- Westin Myles – Mid Michigan Community College
2016
- Riley Lewis – Hope College
2015
- Jake Johnson – Central Michigan University
- Jalen Weekly – Mid Michigan Community College
- Mikhail Myles – Central Michigan University
- Austin Ervin – Central Michigan University
2014
- Marcus Moore – Wayne State University
- Mike Fomby – Albion College/Siena Height University
2013
- Jalen Hayes – Oakland University
- Javon Haines- Davenport
- Tanner Beachnau – Central Michigan University
- Taron Gentry – Albion College
- Ahmad Newsome – Southwestern CC
2012
- Jeff Cain – Lansing Community College/Aquinas College/U of D Dearborn
- Jordan Herring – Albion College
2011
- Tyler Tucker – Miami of Ohio (football)
- Dylan Monette – Saginaw Valley University (football)
- Jordan Johnson – Ferris State University (football)
- Tyrin Wade – Lindenwood University
- Devlin Bell – Lansing Community College
- Steve Repikowski – Tulsa College
- Jake Bullock- Aquinas College
2010
- Auston Barnes – Central Michigan University/Bradley University/Bulgaria
- Cameron Sanchez – Lansing Community College
- Marcus Cain – Lansing Community College
- Alex Archmbauchea – Lansing Community College
- Klarissa Bell – Michigan State University
- Malika Glover – Oakland University
2009
- Taylor Ross – Westminster College
- Tristian Greenidge – Walla Walla University
- Chris Williamson – Ferris State / Alma College
- Derek Thompson – Eastern Michigan University
- Jake Silas – University of Buffalo/Canada